If You Like Buffalo Trace, You Will Love This!

Buffalo Trace bourbon has earned a devoted following, and it's easy to see why. Its smooth taste and versatility make it a favorite. But what if it's hard to find or you're in the mood to try something different? There are many other bourbons that share similar qualities. In this article, we'll introduce you to some excellent alternatives to Buffalo Trace that you might find just as enjoyable.

Key Points

• Bowman Brothers Small Batch is a triple-distilled bourbon, believed to use Buffalo Trace's mashbill, and is aged for 6-7 years.
• Eagle Rare 17-Year-Old Bourbon offers a well-balanced flavor with notes of maple and oak, aged for over 19 years.
• William Larue Weller Bourbon stands out with its rich texture and complex flavors, even at a high proof.
• Four Roses Small Batch is a versatile bourbon with similar proof and price to Buffalo Trace, making it a great everyday choice.
• E.H. Taylor, Jr. Single Barrel Bourbon is a premium option with unique flavors, but it can be harder to find and more expensive.

Bowman Brothers Small Batch comes from the A. Smith Bowman Distillery, which became part of the Sazerac Company in 2003. Although they don't produce their own whiskey distillate, it's believed that they source it from Buffalo Trace, adding an interesting connection for Buffalo Trace enthusiasts.

The distillation process for Bowman Brothers Small Batch is distinctive. The whiskey is triple distilled using premium corn, rye, and malted barley. This unique method results in subtle notes of vanilla, spice, and caramel. The number of times the whiskey passes through their special copper still is kept a secret.

Bowman Brothers Small Batch is aged at the distillery for typically 6-7 years, allowing it to develop a complex and rich flavor profile. Expect delightful hints of vanilla, spice, and caramel—perfect for any bourbon lover.

Related: Top 10 Whiskeys For Father's Day

Flavor Profile

Eagle Rare 17-Year-Old Bourbon is cherished for its complex flavor. On the nose, it reveals soft, woodsy, and sweet aromas with hints of maple and oak. The palate offers a balance of maple sweetness and tannic bitterness, with a bold oak flavor. The slightly bitter finish adds a distinctive touch, making for a unique tasting experience.

Aging Process

Aging for at least 17 years, this bourbon develops deep, rich flavors. The lengthy aging enhances its bold character and mature taste, making it a standout choice for bourbon enthusiasts.

Market Availability

Eagle Rare 17-Year-Old Bourbon is highly sought after and can be difficult to find due to limited production. It has earned numerous awards in spirits competitions. If you happen to find a bottle, consider yourself fortunate—it's a prized addition to any collection.

Flavor Experience

William Larue Weller bourbon is celebrated for its creamy, cinnamon, and honey notes. The nose is reminiscent of a dessert, offering a sensory treat. A sip reveals a rich, creamy texture with complex flavors that are hard to define but utterly enjoyable.

Proof and Aging

This bourbon is part of the Buffalo Trace Antique Collection and boasts a high proof of 133.6. Aged for 12 years, it offers an intense and rich experience. Despite its high alcohol content, it remains smooth and flavorful, making it a favorite among bourbon lovers.

Consumer Appeal

Many consider William Larue Weller to be among the top-tier bourbons. It's often described as a whiskey worth trading all others for. Its unique flavor profile and high proof make it stand out in the crowded bourbon market.

Taste and Aroma

Four Roses Small Batch combines high- and low-rye mashbills, aged between 6 to 7 years. This blend results in a bourbon with a rich and balanced taste. You'll find notes of vanilla, caramel, and a touch of spice, making it enjoyable for any occasion.

Cost and Availability

One of the great things about Four Roses Small Batch is its affordability. Priced between $25 and $55, it offers excellent value for its quality. Plus, it's widely available, so you won't have to search far and wide to find a bottle.

Buffalo Trace Comparison

If you enjoy Buffalo Trace, you'll likely appreciate the versatility of Four Roses Small Batch. Both bourbons have similar proof and price points, making Four Roses a great alternative when Buffalo Trace isn't available.

Special Characteristics

E.H. Taylor, Jr. Single Barrel Bourbon is part of the Buffalo Trace Distillery's well-known mashbill #1 family. All E.H. Taylor expressions are Bottled-in-Bond, meaning they are 100 proof and aged for at least four years. Purchasing a bottle of this single barrel variant is like rolling the dice—you could either get an exceptional barrel or a less memorable one. It's higher in price and proof compared to standard Buffalo Trace, but the potential for an extraordinary flavor experience is significant.

Price Range

E.H. Taylor, Jr. Single Barrel Bourbon's price can vary widely. You might find it for around $150, but it can climb to $250 or more. It's a challenge to track down, especially at a reasonable price these days. If you come across it and feel lucky, it could be worth the investment.

Tasting Journey

The experience of tasting E.H. Taylor, Jr. Single Barrel Bourbon is rich and layered. While the flavor profile may differ from bottle to bottle, you can expect a robust and satisfying sip. Often, the caramel corn flavor is followed by a slight bitterness, which serves as an aperitif, leaving you wanting more. If you're a Buffalo Trace fan, you'll likely appreciate the depth and complexity of this bourbon.

Historical Context

Old Forester is one of the oldest bourbon brands, with over a century of history, even surviving Prohibition. In contrast, Buffalo Trace is a more recent name, having been rebranded from the George T. Stagg distillery in the late 1990s. Despite being newer, Buffalo Trace has quickly amassed a loyal following.

Flavor Differences

Buffalo Trace and Old Forester offer distinct flavor profiles. Buffalo Trace is known for its bright, vibrant, and tropical notes, featuring flavors like peach, cherry, and pineapple. On the other hand, Old Forester delivers darker, earthier flavors such as banana, apple, and oak. While both bourbons have a fruity essence, they express it in different ways.

Cost and Availability

Both bourbons are typically priced under $30, making them affordable choices. However, Buffalo Trace can be harder to find due to its popularity and demand. In some areas, it’s easy to find, while in others, it’s a rare treasure. Old Forester, by contrast, is more consistently available.

When comparing grain spirits, Buffalo Trace and Old Forester each have their own strengths. Your decision will ultimately come down to your flavor preferences.

If you love Buffalo Trace but can't get your hands on it or simply want to explore other options, there are several bourbons that could catch your interest. Here are some noteworthy alternatives offering unique flavors and experiences.

Elmer T. Lee

Elmer T. Lee is a single-barrel bourbon named after the master distiller who played a key role in its creation. This bourbon is known for its smooth, rich flavor, featuring notes of vanilla, caramel, and a hint of spice. It's an excellent pick if you're looking for something with a bit more depth than Buffalo Trace.

Knob Creek Single Barrel

Knob Creek Single Barrel is another outstanding alternative. This bourbon is aged for nine years and bottled at a higher proof, resulting in a robust and full-bodied flavor. You'll detect notes of oak, vanilla, and caramel, making it a delightful sipping whiskey. It's ideal for those who prefer a stronger, more intense bourbon experience.

Woodford Reserve

Woodford Reserve is a versatile bourbon that can be enjoyed neat, on the rocks, or in a cocktail. It has a well-balanced flavor profile with hints of dried fruit, vanilla, and a touch of spice. This bourbon is widely available and reasonably priced, making it a dependable choice when Buffalo Trace isn't on the shelf.

Interested in more options beyond Buffalo Trace? Visit our website to explore a wide selection of bourbons, wines, and beers. Don’t miss our special offers and latest arrivals!

If Buffalo Trace is one of your favorites, there are plenty of other bourbons worth trying. From the versatile Four Roses Small Batch to the rich and bold Eagle Rare, these alternatives provide a wide range of flavors and experiences to satisfy your bourbon cravings. Whether you're searching for something similar or ready to explore new options, these bourbons won't let you down. So, when your go-to bottle is out of stock, consider giving these other great whiskeys a try. Cheers to happy sipping!